
November 20th, 2026
Susan Smith, who more than 30 years ago drove her car into a South Carolina lake, drowning her sons while they remained strapped in their car seats, was once again denied parole on Thursday.
Smith, 55, was sentenced to life imprisonment for the 1994 drownings of 3-year-old Michael and 14-month-old Alex, after the jury that had convicted her elected not to impose the death penalty.
Yet under South Carolina law as it then stood, she was entitled to seek parole after 30 years and, should that be refused, at two-year intervals thereafter.
The parole board unanimously denied her parole request in 2024.
The parole board voted unanimously on Thursday to deny parole.
Smith may apply for parole again in 2028.
The boys’ father, David Smith, who vowed at the first hearing to oppose his ex-wife’s release for as long as he can, and the original prosecutors in the case planned an early morning trip to Columbia to again ask that Susan Smith remain in prison.
David Smith had pinned to his jacket, directly over his heart, the selfsame photograph of his young sons that had once been circulated around the world when people believed they had been abducted by a carjacker—the very same one he wore every day to her 1995 trial and her 2024 parole hearing.
"I am aware that I must return here in two years' time — grappling once more, striving to summon the words that will persuade them to keep her behind bars," he said.
David Smith beseeched the parole board to scrutinise his heart.
He remarked that 32 years might appear a considerable span, yet to him it felt as though it were but yesterday that he had buried his boys.
He stated that he was present to advocate on behalf of his sons, who could never stand up for themselves.
“She deprived us of one of the greatest gifts God bestows upon us – life.
She did so deliberately.
It was neither an accident nor a mistake.
She did it deliberately,” he said in testimony Thursday.
Susan Smith’s hearing before the state Department of Probation, Parole and Pardon Services was convened virtually, Smith participating by video call from prison; she required two-thirds support from the seven-member board to secure her release.
Smith asserted that her sons were innocent children undeserving of death.
She professed profound remorse for having killed them and implored the board to afford her an opportunity to leave prison and contribute positively to the world.
She wept at her first hearing, though not on Thursday.
“I am cognizant of the fact that David was never afforded the opportunity to witness Michael and Alex grow up.
You were never afforded the opportunity to see him ride a bike or go to school.
And I am profoundly, deeply sorry for that, and I would go back and change all of it if I could — I would, OK?
I am not the same person I was 32 years ago,” Smith said.
The odds were stacked against her with respect to parole: according to the agency's statistics, the board had granted parole in a mere 4% of the cases that came before it, and the majority of those pertained to non-violent offences.
And Smith’s case ranks among the most notorious ever to come before the board.
She made international headlines in 1994 when, for nine days, she insisted that a Black carjacker had driven away with her sons, when in fact the boys lay at the bottom of John D. Long Lake in Union County.
Smith’s claims—Smith being white—dovetailed with a centuries-old racist trope casting Black men as a menace to white women, and they inflamed anxieties about crime that were pervasive in 1990s America and persist to this day.
Prosecutors have long maintained that Smith killed her sons because she believed they were the reason the wealthy son of the owner of the business where she worked broke off their affair.
"Susan made that choice out of sheer selfishness.
She genuinely believed she could start her life afresh with someone else by ridding herself of these children," said Tommy Pope, who served as a prosecutor at Smith's trial.
At her trial 30 years ago, Smith and her attorneys attributed her actions to her mental health, asserting that she had intended to enter the lake with her sons but had changed her mind at the last moment.
Her lawyer stated on Thursday that she has no other criminal history and would pose a low risk of ever committing a crime again.
Psychologist Jessie Hill said at the parole hearing that Smith's roiling mental illness had been greatly subdued thanks to medicine, hormonal changes from menopause and the deaths of her mother and stepfather, who admitted in court that he had sexually abused his stepdaughter from before she was a teenager.
Pope said she relished the attention she garnered when she lied about her children having been kidnapped for nine days, and that she has continued to do so behind bars, seeking relationships with men or endeavoring to capitalize on the fame that accrued from being notorious and a true crime sensation.
Pope said David Smith had told him he had always been apprehensive about encountering his ex-wife in the grocery store were she to be released.
Pope said that in contemporary society it would be even worse.
“If you think this family has been through hell now, imagine every day if you pick up your phone or you turn on your computer and there’s Susan talking because you know the letters that have been written, there are people out there that idolize Susan,” Pope said.
Over the course of nine days in 1994, Smith issued numerous and at times tearful entreaties that Michael and Alex be returned unharmed.
Ultimately, however, she would confess.
A re-creation staged by investigators demonstrated that six minutes elapsed before Smith's Mazda dipped beneath the surface, while cameras mounted inside the vehicle captured water surging in through the vents and rising inexorably.
The boys' bodies were discovered suspended upside-down in their car seats, one tiny hand pressed against a window.
November 20th, 2026

Thomas Markle, Meghan’s father, deemed competent to face child sex abuse images case, expert says
Thomas Markle, Meghan’s father, deemed competent to face child sex abuse images case, expert says

Torrential storms track northward to Florida’s Space Coast, precipitating rescues of humans and horses
Torrential storms track northward to Florida’s Space Coast, precipitating rescues of humans and horses

Prosecutor Declines Charges Against Madison, Wisconsin Officer in Fatal Shooting of Black Man
Prosecutor Declines Charges Against Madison, Wisconsin Officer in Fatal Shooting of Black Man

US Catholic Bishops Convene as Democratic Landslide Victories Reshape Immigration and Abortion Debates
US Catholic Bishops Convene as Democratic Landslide Victories Reshape Immigration and Abortion Debates

Trump petitions state and federal courts to vacate hush money conviction
Trump petitions state and federal courts to vacate hush money conviction

Mullin defends government plane use for LSU-Texas game despite ground stop
Mullin defends government plane use for LSU-Texas game despite ground stop

US and Mexico Lose Measles Elimination Status
US and Mexico Lose Measles Elimination Status

Massive gas plume billows from California landfill
Massive gas plume billows from California landfill

Colossal swells batter California’s coastline, compelling the closure of its iconic piers
Colossal swells batter California’s coastline, compelling the closure of its iconic piers