Loading your language..
250 years and counting: the American willingness to be duped

250 years and counting: the American willingness to be duped

C2🇹🇼 中文🇺🇸 English

September 18th, 2026

250 years and counting: the American willingness to be duped

C2
Please note: This article has been simplified for language learning purposes. Some context and nuance from the original text may have been modified or removed.

🇺🇸 English

America: a promised land brimming with boundless opportunity; yet, at the same time, a nation that churns out suckers in droves.

美國:一片充滿無限機遇的應許之地;與此同時,卻也是冤大頭輩出的國度。

We have always held fast to the belief that anything is possiblewhether or not it has any basis in realityand it is precisely this conviction that has propelled this nation into the ranks of the world's largest economies.

我們素來篤信凡事皆有可能——無論其有無現實依據——正是此一信念成就了這個國家躋身世界最大經濟體之列

It has also caused us, time and again, to fall deeply under the spell of swindlers and quacks.

亦令我們一次又一次地深深迷戀上騙徒江湖郎中

If such a profusion of possibilities exists here in America, who can say that the next novel supplement, emerging gadget, or ingenious scam will not simultaneously restore your youth, fortify your health, and line your pockets with wealthor even deliver all these aspirations in one fell swoop?

倘若在美國此地存在如許紛繁之可能誰又能斷言下一款嶄新補充劑新興裝置抑或新穎騙局必不能令你同時返老還童、身強體健腰纏萬貫甚或諸般願景一舉兼得?

In 1897, a Baptist minister convinced us that the company under his command could extract gold from the seawater off the coast near Lubec, Maine.

1897年一位浸信會牧師使我們深信其麾下公司得以自緬因州盧貝克鄰近海域的海水中淬煉出黃金

Meanwhile, a company in East Orange, New Jersey, called Bailey Radium Laboratories, launched a wildly popular product in 1925"Radithor"marketing it as "a cure for the living dead" and claiming it could restore vitality and cure impotence.

而紐澤西州東橘市一家名為貝利鐳實驗室的公司,則於1925年推出一款風靡一時的產品——「鐳水」(Radithor)並將其標榜為「活死人的解藥」聲稱能重煥生機治癒陽痿

There was no gold in the seawater off Maine; nor did Radithor ever transform anyone into an Adonisit poisoned people with radiation.

緬因州的海水之中並不存在黃金;而鐳水亦未曾將人蛻變為阿多尼斯——它以輻射荼毒了人們。

Americans were once so thoroughly duped by swindlers that their tricks have by now become embedded in everyday language.

美國人曾遭騙徒誆騙得如此徹底,以致其騙術於今已然融入日常用語之中。

The United States introduced us to "Rattlesnake King" Clark Stanley, who peddled to us his so-called "snake oil liniment," touting its ability to cure "pain and lameness, rheumatism, neuralgia, sciatica, sprains, bunions," to heal "partial paralysis of the upper and lower limbs," and even to "restore swollen joints to their natural size."

美利堅合眾國為我們引介了響尾蛇王克拉克·史丹利此人向我們兜售所謂的蛇油搽劑」,標榜其能療癒疼痛與跛行風濕病神經痛坐骨神經痛扭傷拇趾囊腫」,並能治癒上肢與下肢之局部癱瘓」,更可使腫脹之關節回復其天然尺寸」。

America also gave rise to Charles Ponzi, who, on the strength of an investment in postal reply coupons alone, could deliver a fifty percent profit in the space of a mere forty-five days.

美國亦催生了查爾斯·龐茲此人僅憑郵票券之投資便能在短短四十五日之內饋以百分之五十之利潤

These hackneyed examples may be all too easy to laugh at or to make one squirm with embarrassment, yet we would do well to be on our guard: we are, with unwavering consistency, only too willing to credit claims that would appear absurd on the slightest exercise of common sense.

這些陳腐的例證固然極易引人發噱令人赧然然則吾人理當戒慎恐懼我們始終如一地甘願採信那些僅需訴諸些許常識判斷便顯得荒誕不經的主張

Does raw milk possess extraordinary powers? Can peptides restore us to youth? Can a hangover be dispelled by injecting large quantities of vitamins intravenously?

生乳蘊含殊異功效胜肽得以令吾人返老還童?藉由靜脈注射大量維生素即可消解宿醉

Why do we so repeatedly fall into traps of this kind?

何以我們屢屢墮入此類圈套

The reason is at once plain and heartrending: "people simply do not wish to confront death."

箇中緣由既淺顯又令人鼻酸:「人著實不願直面死亡。」

So says Dr. Lydia Kang, associate professor of internal medicine at the University of Nebraska Medical Center and author of Quackery, a history of medical fads.

內布拉斯加大學醫學中心內科副教授著有醫學時尚史《庸醫》一書莉迪亞·康恩博士作如是言

A certain desperation underlies this.

箇中蘊含著一種絕望

"Deep down, everyone longs for a long and abundant life," she says, "free of disability or pain, with the mind intact."

每個人內心深處無不渴望擁有長久而豐盛的人生,」她說道,「沒有失能或疼痛而且頭腦完好。」

Other experts point out that there are in fact sociological and evolutionary reasons behind why people are drawn to absurd, even outright debunked, claims.

其他專家指出,人們之所以會受荒誕不經、甚或已然遭到推翻的主張所吸引,其背後實則蘊含社會學與演化層面上的成因。

Admittedly, this is not unique to the United States.

誠然美國所獨有

Yet the reason these instincts and proclivities are magnified to such an unbounded degree in America lies in the almost ruthless optimism prevailing here, in a deeply entrenched spirit of individualism, in a capitalist system marked by lax regulation, in an almost obsessive fervour for wealth, health and beauty, and in a covetousness driven by suspicion and a desire to claim a share of the spoils: others are surely all exploiting the loopholes in the system, so why shouldn't I?

然而這些本能與傾向在美國之所以被無限放大實緣於此間那種近乎冷酷的樂觀主義根深蒂固的個人主義精神監管鬆弛的資本主義體制對財富、健康與美貌近乎偏執的狂熱追求,以及一種由猜忌所驅使欲從中分一杯羹的貪念他人定然皆在鑽制度的空子那我何嘗不可

"This is a scenario straight out of a Wild West cowboy film," Cohn remarked.

這儼然是狂野西部牛仔片的典型情境,」康恩說道

"People will reason, 'Well, if you won't do it, then I'll simply take matters into my own hands.'"

人們會忖度,『罷了倘若你不為之那我便親力親為。』」

When we hold certain propositions with unwavering conviction, or cling to them even after they have been refuted, it does not necessarily follow that we are ignorant or foolish.

當我們對某些主張深信不疑,抑或在它們遭推翻之後仍執迷不悟時我們未必就是愚昧無知的

Tali Sharot, Professor of Neuroscience at University College London, points out that human beings do not hold beliefs in order to construct an accurate representation of the world.

倫敦大學學院神經科學教授塔莉·沙羅特指出人類之所以懷有信念並非旨在構築對世界的精確再現

She explains that beliefs serve merely "to enable us to reap the greatest rewards and to help us avoid harm.

她闡明信念僅是為了讓我們獲取最大回報並助我們規避傷害

Such beliefs are sometimes accurate, and sometimes they are not."

這些信念有時準確無誤,有時則不然。」

She explains that, for instance, overconfidence may help you find a partner, or else secure a job for which you are utterly unqualified.

她闡述道譬如過度自信或可襄助覓得伴侶抑或謀得一職你壓根兒不夠格勝任的工作

By fervently believing what others in the group believe, people can attain a sense of community, support, and belonging.

人們得以藉由篤信群體中他人所篤信的獲致社群感支持與歸屬感

"Even if that belief is erroneous, it does no harm," Sharot says.

縱然那是錯誤的信念亦無傷大雅,」沙羅特說道

The conviction that vaccines and autism are causally linkedeven though conclusive evidence has thoroughly refuted this misconceptionnot only furnishes families and their loved ones with a target for blame, but also enables them to find solace and support within a community that shares their resentment, fear, and anguish.

篤信疫苗與自閉症存有因果關聯——縱然確鑿證據已徹底否證此一謬見——不僅為家庭及其至親提供了一個可供歸咎的對象,更使他們得以從一個同懷憤懣、恐懼與痛苦的群體中覓得慰藉與支持。

Yet hope and belief are capable of engendering a kind of optimisma conviction that things may well improvewhich in turn can, at least temporarily, alleviate one's mood and mental health.

而希望與信念足以催生一種樂觀情緒使人相信事態或將好轉而這反過來至少能暫時緩解心境與心理健康

Sharot remarked, "Believing that your future will be better than your past and your presenteven if your future does not in fact turn out to be bettermay, more often than not, prove to be an optimal strategy."

沙羅特說:「相信你的未來會比過去和現在更好——即便你的未來不會更好——很多時候這可能是一種最優策略。」

Buying a lottery ticket amounts to an almost guaranteed lossit is a poor financial decision.

購買彩券幾乎形同保證虧損——此乃一項拙劣的財務決策

People are perfectly aware of this.

人們對此心知肚明

Yet they are equally aware that a lottery ticket carries with it a glimmer of hopean opportunity to envision a more affluent future.

然而他們同樣明白,一張彩券承載著一縷希望,是一個得以想像更為富裕之未來的契機。

"What you are certain to get is the pleasure of contemplating it," she says.

確定所購得的思索此事的樂趣,」她說道

"That is what you are guaranteed to receive."

那是保證能獲得的東西。」

When it comes to supplements, salves, and therapies that tout benefits bordering on the fantastical, our response follows the same pattern.

論及那些標榜著近乎天方夜譚般效益補充劑藥膏與療法時,我們的反應亦如出一轍

On the one hand, they amount to nothing more than a futile squandering of hard-earned money, sometimes accompanied by adverse side effects.

一方面它們無異於對血汗錢的徒然虛擲有時更伴隨負面副作用

On the other hand, "you do derive something from the attempt," Sarot points outthings such as positive anticipation or a sense of excitement.

另一方面,「你確實從嘗試中有所收穫,」沙羅特指出諸如正向的期待或興奮感

Yet this very propensity renders us easy prey for companies that covet our money, and they are consummately adept at what they do.

然而,此等傾向使我們易於淪為那些覬覦我們錢財的公司所宰制,而彼等對其所為之事可謂駕輕就熟。

Surveying American history, a clear pattern leaps off the page: the moment the faintest glimmer of evidence emerges that some measure might actually work, the door cracks open a sliver, and corporations seize the opening to march straight in, preying on the desperationand the paychecksof those who are suffering, worn down, or gripped by fear.

縱觀美國歷史一個清晰的模式躍然紙上但凡某項舉措可能奏效蛛絲馬跡乍現門扉便隨之裂開一道縫隙而企業則趁勢長驅直入攫取那些飽受煎熬心力交瘁或驚惶不安之人的絕望——以及他們的薪水

Dr. Benjamin Rush, a Philadelphia physician and a signatory of the Declaration of Independence, was profoundly frustrated by his inability to save lives during the raging yellow fever epidemic of 1793.

費城內科醫師獨立宣言簽署人班傑明·拉什博士於1793年黃熱病疫情肆虐之際因回天乏術而深感挫敗

Subsequently, he perused several autopsy reports that hinted purging and bloodletting might prove efficacious.

其後他披閱若干屍檢報告其中隱約揭示催瀉與放血或可奏效

He therefore resorted to a desperate gamble, administering high doses of calomel and jalap to his patientsthe former a mercury compound, the latter a powder derived from a Mexican plant root, which in combination constituted a drastic purgativewhile simultaneously subjecting them to copious bloodletting.

遂鋌而走險對病患投以高劑量之甘汞與賈拉普——一者為汞化合物一者為墨西哥植物根部粉末二者併用即成峻烈瀉劑——同時大肆為之放血

As one document records: "So much blood flowed in the front yard that the stench there was overpowering, and the buzzing of flies was incessant."

據一份文獻所載:「前院淌血之多致使該處穢氣熏天蠅聲嗡嗡不絕。」

Charles Stanley's snake oil was utterly spuriousthe United States Bureau of Chemistry established in 1916 that its composition consisted chiefly of mineral oil, containing "a fatty oil (possibly beef tallow), capsicum, and possibly traces of camphor or turpentine."

查爾斯·史丹利的蛇油純屬偽劣——美國化學局於1916年查明其成分主要為礦物油內含脂肪油或係牛脂)、辣椒以及或然微量之樟腦松節油」。

Yet its inspiration in fact derived from Chinese labourers, whose own preparation was an oil extracted from a particular species of snake and may indeed have possessed a certain anti-inflammatory efficacy.

然其靈感實源自中國勞工彼等所使用者乃萃取自某一特定蛇種之油或確具若干抗炎之效

Radiation's utility in medicine, whether past or present, is undeniable; this fact opened the door for William J. A. Bailey to market radium water as a "health tonic"—until one prominent and thoroughly convinced patron overdosed, leading to the putrefaction of his jawbone and death from radiation poisoning.

輻射之於醫療無論昔今皆有其用此一事實威廉·J·A·貝利敞開了大門,使其得以將鐳水標榜為健康補品」——直至一位聲名顯赫且篤信不疑的主顧服用過量終致下顎骨腐爛死於輻射中毒

This grey area leaves regulators and health professionals in an awkward bind: to assert categorically that something is ineffective is often far from straightforward, all the more so when no one is willing to expend precious time and resources on research.

灰色地帶監管機構衛生專業人員進退維谷欲明確斷言某事物無效往往殊非易事尤其無人耗費寶貴時間資源進行研究的情況下,更是如此。

In the meantime, companies will come flocking in.

與此同時公司便會蜂擁而至

"The horrifying thing is that they will seize that hope, attempt to bottle it, and then resell it to you at whatever price they deem you can bear," Cohn said.

可怖之處在於他們會攫走那份希望試圖將其封存於瓶中繼而他們認定你所能承受的任何價格轉售予你,」康恩如是說

Countless supplements and unapproved "therapies" base their rationale on the faintest hints of potential benefit observed in animal studies or small observational studies, which are inherently incapable of establishing causation.

無數補充劑未經核准的「療法」其立論基礎皆在於動物研究小型觀察性研究所顯現的潛在益處蛛絲馬跡而此類研究根本無從確立因果關係

Today, some of those yearning for longevity have pinned their hopes on rapamycina drug administered to organ transplant patients that has been shown to extend lifespan in yeast, flies, and mice.

時至今日若干渴求長壽之人已將冀望繫於雷帕黴素——一種施用於器官移植患者之藥物,曾於酵母蒼蠅及小鼠身上延展其壽命

Several remarkably successful drugsinsulin, and even the weight-loss medications Wegovy and Zepboundbelong to the category of peptides, that is, short chains of amino acids that can fold into a countless variety of configurations.

若干成就斐然的藥物——胰島素乃至減重製劑Wegovy與Zepbound——皆屬胜肽之列亦即短鏈胺基酸其可摺疊成無以計數的構型

This fact has spawned an entire industry dedicated to marketing other peptidesmost of them neither proven nor testedthat are claimed to promote muscle growth, accelerate recovery, and deliver anti-aging effects.

此一事實催生了一整條產業鏈專事推銷其他胜肽——多數既未經證實亦未經檢驗——據稱可促進肌肉增生加速恢復並收抗衰老之效

Does this rhetoric sound familiar?

此番說辭聽來是否似曾相識

Of course, science, technology, and this country's relentlessly driven economic engine have spawned countless genuine miracles and enduring legends; and all of this, in turn, has loosened the soil for credulous minds to take root.

當然科學技術以及這個國家那具無情驅力的經濟引擎業已催生出無數貨真價實的奇蹟歷久彌新的軼聞而這一切反過來又為輕信之心智疏鬆了滋生的土壤。

We are able, within the span of a few hours, to traverse the entire country aboard a metallic tubular flying machine.

我們得以在數小時之內乘坐金屬管狀飛行器橫越全國

We are able, by means of a small sliver of metal and glass, to access virtually the entirety of humankind's accumulated knowledge.

我們得以憑藉一小片金屬與玻璃觸及幾乎全人類的知識總和

Advances in medicine, vaccination in particulara notion once deemed radicalhave all but eradicated the childhood diseases that, in the nation's founding era, were capable of claiming the lives of half of all children under the age of five.

醫學之進展尤以疫苗接種為然——此一概念曾屬激進——已近乎根絕建國時期足以奪走半數五歲以下兒童性命童年疾病

An American born in 1900 could expect to live a mere 47 years or so.

1900年出生的美國人預期壽命不過約47歲

Today, American life expectancy has reached 79 years, the highest ever recorded.

時至今日美國人的預期壽命已達79歲為有史以來最高

Who would dare assert that it cannot double once more?

誰敢斷言它不能再翻倍

And why should there be any limit whatsoever?

又何以應有任何極限

We are perhaps more susceptible to being swayed now than at any other moment in history.

我們如今或許比歷史上任何時刻都更易於受到左右

Kahn observes that we are being bombarded by an ever-denser barrage of seductive claims, because the devices in our pockets ceaselessly deliver hawkerseuphemistically dubbed "influencers"who peddle "cures" and other shortcuts, catering to our 250-year-long pursuit of happiness.

康恩指出我們正遭受日益密集的誘人主張之轟炸因為口袋裡的裝置源源不絕地輸送叫賣者——被委婉冠以「網紅」之名——他們兜售「療法」及其他終南捷徑迎合我們長達250年追求幸福的歷程。

Social media is exceedingly adept at replicating the very type of message that scientists have identified as the one our brains are most inclined to believe: direct, personalised appeals emanating from individuals who appear credible and who claim to possess first-hand experience.

社群媒體極其精於複製科學家所指出我們大腦最傾向採信訊息類型源自看似可信、且自稱擁有親身經歷者所發出的直接而個人化的訴求

And in the United States, it may also serve as a particularly alluring alternative to a healthcare system that is expensive, impersonal, and absurdly difficult to navigate.

而在美國它亦可能成為格外誘人的替代選項用以取代昂貴冷漠荒謬地難以駕馭醫療體系

Even the highest-ranking public health official in the United StatesSecretary of Health and Human Services Robert F. Kennedy Jr.has promoted or lent his voice to those advocating for or peddling unproven remedies and wellness products, a range that encompasses the use of vitamin A as a treatment for measles, as well as peptides and raw milk.

甚至連美國最高公共衛生官員——衛生部長小羅伯特·F·甘迺迪——亦曾推廣為那些倡導販售未經證實療法保健產品發聲其範疇涵蓋將維生素A用作麻疹治療以及胜肽生牛奶

"The guardrails have now utterly vanished," Cohn said.

護欄如今已然蕩然無存,」康恩說道

"In fact, the situation is even more perilous than it once was, and the reason lies in social media, in the various content found online, and in those ostensibly trustworthy figures whose counsel we ought to be able to rely upon but who are, in reality, anything but credible.

實則情勢較諸往昔更形險峻其故在於社群媒體,在於網路上的種種內容亦在於那些我們理當仰賴其建言實則並不可信所謂可信之士

For this very reason, I believe this has plunged the American public into even graver peril."

職是之故我以為這使美國大眾陷於更為深重的危殆之中。」

George C. Parker, that consummate American swindler who time and again managed to sell off the Brooklyn Bridge for cash, would surely have relished such a state of affairs; what is more, he would undoubtedly have concocted a scheme on your behalf with the utmost cunning.

那位曾屢次將布魯克林大橋脫手變現的曠世美國騙徒喬治·C·帕克,勢必會對這般局面欣然稱快;不僅如此,他定然還會為你精心謀劃一樁交易。

Jonathan Fay serves as the global health and science editor for Reporters.

強納森·費伊《Reporters》全球健康與科學編輯

Health and science coverage published in Reporters is financially supported by the Journalists' News Fund and private foundations.

《Reporters》所刊健康與科學相關報導,乃記者新聞基金私人基金會之財務挹注

The Associated Press bears sole responsibility for all of its content.

美聯社就其全部內容獨自承擔責任。

Guidelines governing the Associated Press's collaborations with philanthropic organizations, a roster of supporters, and the scope of funded coverage are all available for consultation at AP.org.

有關美聯社與慈善機構合作之準則支持者名錄受資助報導範疇均可於AP.org查閱

September 18th, 2026

Trending Articles

A truck driver built a model of New York City with over 800,000 buildings, purely for his own amusement, and now it has unexpectedly become a museum exhibit.

A truck driver built a model of New York City with over 800,000 buildings, purely for his own amusement, and now it has unexpectedly become a museum exhibit.

一名卡車司機以逾80萬棟建築構築紐約市模型,純為自娛,如今竟成博物館展品

C2Sep 18
DoorDash and Uber Eats team up to provide delivery services for Costco stores in the United States

DoorDash and Uber Eats team up to provide delivery services for Costco stores in the United States

DoorDash與Uber Eats攜手為美國Costco門市提供外送服務

C2Sep 17
CNN's New Culinary Travel Series: Chef David Chang Hits the Road Across America

CNN's New Culinary Travel Series: Chef David Chang Hits the Road Across America

CNN新美食旅遊系列 主廚大衛·張橫跨美國上路

C2Sep 17
The Great American Road Trip: The Car Both Made It and Broke It

The Great American Road Trip: The Car Both Made It and Broke It

偉大的美國公路旅行:汽車既推動其成,亦促其衰

C2Sep 14
The golf ball discovered amidst the ruins of the World Trade Center symbolizes a loss beyond words

The golf ball discovered amidst the ruins of the World Trade Center symbolizes a loss beyond words

世貿中心廢墟中發現的高爾夫球,象徵著難以言喻的損失

C2Sep 11
The apple pie (along with the image of the mother) has already become the nation's symbolic food.

The apple pie (along with the image of the mother) has already become the nation's symbolic food.

蘋果派(連同母親的形象)已然成為國家的象徵性食物

C2Sep 9
Gallup Poll Reveals Plummeting American Satisfaction with Schools to Historic Lows

Gallup Poll Reveals Plummeting American Satisfaction with Schools to Historic Lows

Gallup Poll Reveals Plummeting American Satisfaction with Schools to Historic Lows

C2Sep 9
91-year-old "Greybeard" Dale Sanders reclaims the record as the oldest hiker to complete the Appalachian Trail.

91-year-old "Greybeard" Dale Sanders reclaims the record as the oldest hiker to complete the Appalachian Trail.

91歲「灰鬍子」戴爾·桑德斯重奪阿巴拉契亞小徑最年長徒步完成者紀錄

C2Sep 1
Autumn Garden Chrysanthemum Selection and Appraisal—Transcending Traditional Cushion-Form Chrysanthemum Artistry

Autumn Garden Chrysanthemum Selection and Appraisal—Transcending Traditional Cushion-Form Chrysanthemum Artistry

秋季花園菊品選鑑——超越傳統墊狀菊藝

C2Sep 1