Loading your language..
A 250-Year Unresolved Perplexity: Why Do the American People Willingly Submit to Deception?

A 250-Year Unresolved Perplexity: Why Do the American People Willingly Submit to Deception?

C2🇨🇳 中文🇺🇸 English

September 18th, 2026

A 250-Year Unresolved Perplexity: Why Do the American People Willingly Submit to Deception?

C2
Please note: This article has been simplified for language learning purposes. Some context and nuance from the original text may have been modified or removed.

🇺🇸 English

America: a promised land brimming with boundless possibilities; yet equally a quagmire where the credulous meet their downfall.

美国:一片充满无限可能应许之地亦是一片令轻信者折戟沉沙渊薮

We hold fast to the conviction that anything is possiblewhether or not it is grounded in realityand it is precisely this conviction that has propelled the United States to its ascent as the world's largest economy.

我们笃信一切皆有可能——无论其是否植根于现实——正是这一信念助推美国跃升为全球最大经济体

It has also, time and again, left us hopelessly enthralled by charlatans and quacks.

屡屡令我们无可救药地痴迷于骗徒江湖郎中

If so many possibilities already exist here in America, who can say that the next new supplement, device, or regimen could not make you young, strong, and wealthy all at onceor some combination thereof?

倘若在美国此地,如此之多的可能性皆已存在,谁又能断言下一款新补充剂、新设备或新方案,不可能令你同时臻于年轻、强壮、富有,抑或兼而有之?

In 1897, a Baptist minister persuaded us to believe that his company could extract gold from the seawater near Lubec, Maine.

1897年一位浸信会牧师令我们笃信其公司能够自缅因州卢贝克附近的海水中提炼出黄金

In 1925, a company in East Orange, New Jersey, called the Bailey Radium Laboratories brought out a wildly popular product, Radithor, advertised as "a cure for the living dead" and claimed to restore vitality and cure impotence.

新泽西州东奥兰治一家名为贝利镭实验室的公司于1925年推出了一款风靡一时的产品Radithor广告中将其标榜为“活死人的解药”宣称可恢复活力并治愈阳痿

The waters off Maine harbor no gold, nor did Radithor ever sculpt anyone into an Adonis-like paragon of beauty; with radiation as its blade, it poisoned those who consumed it.

缅因州的海域中并无黄金蕴藏,而Radithor亦未曾将人塑造成阿多尼斯般的俊美形象;它以辐射为刃,荼毒了那些服用者。

Americans have repeatedly been duped by swindlers of extraordinary audacity, whose schemes were so ingenious that they have by now become embedded in everyday language.

美国人曾屡遭胆大包天的骗子蒙蔽,其骗术之诡谲,竟至如今已融入日常用语之中。

America gave us Clark Stanleythe self-styled "Rattlesnake King" — who peddled his so-called "snake oil liniment," claiming it could remedy "pain and lameness, for rheumatism, neuralgia, sciatica, sprains, bunions," cure "partial paralysis of the upper and lower limbs," and "reduce swollen joints to natural size."

美国引进了克拉克·斯坦利——号称响尾蛇之王”——此人向我们兜售所谓蛇油搽剂”,宣称可疗愈疼痛与跛行适用于风湿神经痛坐骨神经痛扭伤拇囊炎”,能治愈上肢及下肢部分瘫痪”,并“使肿胀的关节回缩至自然尺寸”。

America also produced Charles Ponzi, who, under the guise of a postal-reply-coupon investment scheme, promised a 50 percent return in a mere 45 days.

美国亦催生了查尔斯·庞兹邮票券投资为幌子许诺短短45天内即可奉上50%的回报。

These hoary examples may easily provoke mirth or a pang of shame, yet we ought to remain circumspect: we are as willing as ever to credit claims that, upon even the slightest application of common sense, stand revealed as preposterous.

这些陈旧的例证极易引人发噱令人汗颜然而我们理应保持审慎:我们一如既往地甘愿轻信那些即便仅经些许常识检验亦显荒诞不经的说法

Does raw milk possess extraordinary virtues?

生牛奶具有特殊功效

Can peptides restore us to youth?

能令我们重返青春?

Can megadoses of intravenous vitamins dispel a hangover?

经静脉注射大剂量维生素可消解宿醉

Why do we so often fall prey to deception?

何以我们屡屡受骗

The reason is at once simple and disheartening: "people are profoundly unwilling to die."

其缘由简单令人扼腕:“人着实不愿赴死。”

So says Dr. Lydia Kang, an associate professor of internal medicine at the University of Nebraska Medical Center.

内布拉斯加大学医学中心内科副教授莉迪亚·康博士如是说

She is the author of a book examining medical fads, titled Quackery.

曾著有一部探讨医学时尚的著作题为《庸医》

Within this lies a kind of desperation.

这其中蕴含着一种绝望

"Deep in everyone's heart is a profound desire to have a long and fruitful life," she says, "without disability or suffering, with the brain intact."

每个人的内心深处都怀有一个深切的愿望即拥有长久而富有成果的人生,”她说道,“没有残疾或痛苦大脑完好无损。”

Other experts point out that there are sociological and evolutionary reasons behind why people are drawn to bizarre, even discredited, claims.

另有一些专家指出,人们之所以会被那些怪诞乃至已被证伪的论调所吸引,背后存在着社会学与进化层面的成因。

Admittedly, this is by no means a phenomenon unique to the United States.

诚然美国所独有之现象

Yet in America these instincts and proclivities are magnified, attended as they are by a remorseless optimism, an individualistic ethos, a lightly regulated capitalism, a frantic ambition to become richer, healthier or more beautiful, and a suspicion-driven desire to get in on the act: surely others have already gamed the system, so why shouldn't I?

然而这些本能与倾向在美国得到了放大与其无情的乐观主义个人主义精神监管宽松的资本主义对变得更富有、更健康或更漂亮的拼命野心,以及一种由怀疑驱动的想参与其中的欲望相伴:别人肯定已经钻了制度的空子那我为什么不能

"It has a distinctly Wild West cowboy feel to it," Kang observed.

颇有些狂野西部牛仔情境况味,”说道

"People think to themselves, 'Well, if you won't do it, then I'll just go ahead and do it myself.'"

人们暗自思忖,‘也罢倘若不为之那我便亲力为之。’”

When we firmly believe certain propositions, or cling to them even after they have been falsified, we are not necessarily being foolish.

当我们笃信某些论断,抑或在它们遭证伪之后仍执守不渝时,我们未必就是在犯傻。

Tali Sharot, a professor of neuroscience at University College London, points out that the purpose of our holding beliefs is not to construct an accurate representation of the world.

伦敦大学学院神经科学教授塔利·沙罗特指出我们之所以拥有信念其目的并非在于建构对世界的精准表征

She goes on to explain that it is simply "in order to hold beliefs that bring us the greatest rewards and help us avoid harm.

她进而阐明这不过是为了拥有能给我们带来最大回报并帮助我们规避伤害的信念

Sometimes these beliefs are accurate, but sometimes they are not."

有时这些信念是准确的但有时则不然。”

For instance, she points out, overconfidence may help you win a partner, or else land a job for which you are not actually qualified.

譬如她指出过度自信或可助你赢得伴侣抑或谋得一份你本不具备资格工作

And by believing what others in the group believe, people gain a sense of community, support, and belonging.

而通过信奉群体中他人所信奉之物,人们则能获得社区感支持与归属感

"If it's a false belief, that's fine," Sharot says.

倘若这是一种错误信念那也无妨,”沙罗特如是说

Although conclusive evidence has already demonstrated that there is no causal link between vaccines and autism, the tenacious adherence to this belief nonetheless furnishes families and their closest kin with an object upon which to pin the blame, and endows them with a sense of belongingsituated as they are within a community of people equally indignant, equally fearful, and equally anguished, mutually sustaining one another and mutually corroborating one another.

尽管确凿证据已然表明疫苗与自闭症之间并无因果关联然而对这一信念的执守却为家庭及其至亲提供了一个可供归咎的对象并赋予他们一种归属感——置身于同样愤懑同样恐惧同样痛苦的群体之中,彼此扶持,彼此印证

Yet hope and belief are sufficient to engender a sense of optimism, fostering the conviction that circumstances may yet take a turn for the better, which in turn can, at least temporarily, redound to the benefit of one's emotional and psychological well-being.

而希冀与信念足以催生一种乐观情绪使人相信事态或有转圜之余地这反过来至少能暂时裨益于情绪与心理健康

"To hold fast to the conviction that your future will surpass your past and your presenteven if your future will not in fact be any better," Sharot observes, "may, under many circumstances, prove to be the optimal course of action."

笃信你的未来将优于你的过往与当下——即便你的未来并不会真的更好,”沙罗特如是说,“在诸多情形下这或许不失为最优解。”

A lottery ticket is all but guaranteed to leave you financially worse offit is an utterly deplorable financial decision.

彩票几乎注定会使你蒙受经济损失——这是一项糟糕透顶的财务决策

People are perfectly well aware of this.

人们对此心知肚明

Yet they are equally cognizant that a lottery ticket carries with it a glimmer of hope, an opportunity to indulge in reveries of a more prosperous future.

然而他们同样明白一张彩票承载着一缕希冀,一个得以遐想更为富足未来的契机。

"What you assuredly purchase is nothing more than the pleasure of contemplating it," she says.

你所笃定购得的无非是思索它时的那份愉悦,”她说

"That is what you are guaranteed to receive."

这是 guaranteed 能够获得的。”

When it comes to supplements, salves, and technologies that promise highly improbable benefits, our thinking follows the same pattern.

当关乎那些承诺着极不可能兑现之裨益的补充剂药膏与技术时,我们的思维亦复如是

On the one hand, they represent a painful waste of hard-earned money, sometimes accompanied by adverse side effects.

一方面它们是对来之不易的钱财的惨痛挥霍有时更伴有负面副作用

On the other hand, "you always get something out of trying," as Sharot puts itsuch as a sense of positive anticipation or excitement.

另一方面,“你从尝试中总有所得,”沙罗特如是说譬如积极的期待或兴奋之感

Yet it is precisely such tendencies that render us easy prey for companies coveting our money, and these companies are thoroughly adept at what they do.

然而此类倾向恰恰令我们易于沦为那些觊觎我们钱财的公司的俎上之肉,而后者于其所从事之事可谓驾轻就熟

Throughout American history, a stark pattern emerges with unmistakable clarity: the moment a hint that something might work pries open the slightest crack in the door, corporations storm straight through, seizing the desperation of the wounded, the weary, or the fearfuland their paychecks along with it.

纵观美国历史,一个清晰的模式赫然浮现:一旦某事物可能奏效的暗示在门上撬开一道缝隙,企业便长驱直入,攫取那些受伤、疲惫或恐惧之人的绝望——以及他们的薪水。

Dr. Benjamin Rush was a practicing physician in Philadelphia and one of the signatories of the Declaration of Independence.

本杰明·拉什医生身为费城的一位执业医师亦为《独立宣言》的签署者之一

When the yellow fever epidemic was raging in 1793, he was deeply disheartened by his utter inability to save his patients.

1793年黄热病疫情肆虐之际因回天乏术而倍感沮丧

Thereafter, he pored over autopsy reports, which hinted that purging and bloodletting might prove effective.

嗣后,他披阅尸检报告其中暗示催泻与放血或可奏效

So he took this to its extreme, administering large doses of calomel and jalap to his patientsa mercury compound combined with a powdered Mexican plant root, the two together forming an exceptionally powerful purgativewhile vigorously applying bloodletting as well.

于是他将其推向极致,给病人服用大剂量的甘汞与jalap——一种汞化合物与一种墨西哥植物根粉的混合物二者合而为极强的泻药——同时积极施以放血疗法

As one account put it: "So much blood flowed in the front yard that it became foul-smelling and buzzing with flies."

据一份记载所云:“前院流淌了太多血液以至于那里变得恶臭并嗡嗡飞着苍蝇。”

Charles Stanley's snake oil was utterly spurious: in 1916 the United States Bureau of Chemistry determined that its composition consisted chiefly of mineral oil, along with "fatty oil (possibly beef tallow), capsicum, and possibly traces of camphor or turpentine."

查尔斯·斯坦利蛇油纯属伪劣之品——1916年美国化学局查明其成分以矿物油为主另含脂肪油或为牛脂)、辣椒以及可能微量的樟脑松节油”。

Yet the notion itself actually originated with Chinese labourers, and the oil they usedextracted from one highly specific species of snakemay indeed have possessed a certain anti-inflammatory efficacy.

然而此一构想实源自中国劳工彼等所用之油——取自某一极为特定的蛇种——或许确具若干抗炎之效

Radiation has had medical applications both in the past and in the present, which opened the door for William J. A. Bailey to market his Radithor as a "health tonic"until one notably prominent and overzealous customer took an excessive dose, causing his jawbone to rot away and ultimately dying of radiation poisoning.

辐射在过往与当下皆具医学应用为威廉·J·A·贝利将其Radithor作为“健康补品”加以推销敞开了门户——直至一位声名显赫且热忱过度的顾客服用过量致使下颌骨腐坏并最终死于辐射中毒

This grey area leaves regulators and health professionals mired in a quandary: to assert categorically that something is ineffective is often simply impossible, all the more so when no one is willing to expend precious time and resources on conducting research.

灰色地带监管者卫生专业人员深陷困局欲明确断言某物无效往往无从谈起尤其无人甘愿耗费宝贵时间资源开展研究的情形下,更是如此。

Meanwhile, companies swoop in.

与此同时公司便猛扑上来

"The terrible thing is that they seize upon that hope, try to bottle it, and then sell it back to you at whatever price they reckon you can bear," Kang said.

可怕之处在于他们会攫取那份希望试图将其封入瓶中他们认定你所能承受的任何价格兜售给你,”康说道

Countless supplements and unapproved "treatments" have their origins in the faintest hints of potential benefit suggested by animal experiments or small observational studiesresearch that is fundamentally incapable of establishing causation.

无数补充剂未经批准的“治疗”皆源于动物实验小型观察性研究中所示潜在获益蛛丝马迹,而此类研究根本无从确立因果关系

As things stand today, some of those devoted to prolonging life have pinned their hopes on rapamycina drug administered to organ transplant recipientswhich has been shown to extend the lifespan of yeast, flies, and mice.

时至今日一些矢志于延年益寿者已将希冀寄予雷帕霉素——一种供器官移植患者使用的药物,它曾延长酵母苍蝇小鼠的寿命。

Several remarkably successful drugsinsulin and the weight-loss medications Wegovy and Zepbound among themare peptides, that is, short chains of amino acids capable of folding into a myriad of configurations.

若干成就斐然的药物——诸如胰岛素以及减肥药物WegovyZepbound——皆属肽类能够折叠无数构型氨基酸链

This has spawned an entire industry peddling other peptideslargely unproven and untestedthat are purported to promote muscle growth, hasten recovery, and combat ageing.

此举催生了一整个产业推销的是其他肽类——大多未经证实检验——据称可促进肌肉生长加速恢复对抗衰老

Does this sound at all familiar?

听起来是否似曾相识

Admittedly, science, technology, and this country's ruthlessly efficient economic engine have already spawned countless genuine miracles and enduring anecdotes; and all of this, in turn, has loosened the soil for credulity.

诚然,科学、技术以及这个国家那冷酷无情的经济引擎,已然催生出无数名副其实的奇迹与历久弥新的轶事;而这一切,反过来又为轻信之心松软了土壤。

We are able, within a matter of hours, to traverse the entire country in metallic flying tubes.

我们得以在数小时之内搭乘金属质地的飞行管道横贯全国

We are able, by means of a small slab of metal and glass, to seize hold of virtually the entirety of human knowledge.

我们得以凭借一小块金属与玻璃攫取几乎全部人类知识

Advances in medicine, vaccination above allonce a radical notionhave all but eradicated the pediatric diseases that, at the nation's founding, carried off as many as half of all children before their fifth year.

医学的进步尤其是疫苗接种——这一度曾是一个激进的概念——已近乎根除建国之初致使多达半数儿童于五岁前夭折的儿科疾病

An American born in 1900 could expect to live perhaps a mere 47 years.

1900年出生的美国人其预期寿命或许仅为47岁

Today, life expectancy in the United States has reached 79 years, the highest level ever recorded.

如今美国的预期寿命已达79岁为有史以来最高水平

And who is to say it will not double once more?

谁又能断言它不会再度翻倍

And why should there be any ceiling at all?

又何以应当存在任何上限

Kang points out that we may now be more susceptible to influence than at any other time in history.

康指出我们当下或许比历史上任何时期都更易受到左右

We are surrounded by an ever-proliferating array of seductive pitches, all because the devices in our pockets ceaselessly push forth those hawkerseuphemistically dubbed "influencers"peddling every manner of "remedy" and other shortcuts, shadowing our 250-year pursuit of happiness every step of the way.

我们被愈发层出不穷的诱人说辞所环绕皆因口袋中的设备源源不断地推送那些叫卖者——委婉地称之为“影响者”——兜售形形色色的“疗法”及其他捷径与我们250年来追寻幸福的历程如影随形。

Social media is exceptionally adept at mimicking the very kind of information that scientists have revealed our brains are most inclined to accept: direct, personalized appeals emanating from individuals who appear credible and who claim to speak from firsthand experience.

社交媒体极为擅长仿效科学家所揭示的我们大脑最易采信的那类信息:源自看似可信且自称有亲身经历者直接而个人化的诉求

And in the United States, when confronted with a healthcare system that is expensive, dehumanizing, and so absurd as to be unmanageable, it may prove a particularly alluring alternative.

而在美国面对昂贵非人性化荒诞到令人难以驾驭医疗体系它或许尤其构成一种颇具吸引力的替代之选

Even the nation's foremost health official, Secretary of Health Robert F. Kennedy Jr., has endorsed or lent his support to purveyors and promoters of unproven remedies and wellness productsamong them the exaltation of vitamin A as a treatment for measles, along with the likes of peptides and raw milk.

甚至美国最高卫生官员卫生部长小罗伯特·F·肯尼迪宣扬经销未经证实之疗法保健产品者予以推崇或声援其中包括将维生素A奉为麻疹疗法以及生牛奶之流

"The guardrails have now vanished entirely," Kang said.

护栏如今已然荡然无存,”说道

"The reality is, if anything, worse than ever before, and the reason for that lies in social media, in the content circulating on the internet, and in the fact that those supposedly trustworthy figures from whom we ought to be seeking advice are, in truth, anything but trustworthy.

实际情况较之以往可谓有过之而无不及究其原因在于社交媒体,在于互联网上的内容亦在于那些我们本应从中获取建议所谓可信人士实则并不可信

In my view, this has plunged the American public into an even graver predicament of peril."

我认为致使美国公众陷入了更为严峻的危险境地。”

George C. Parker, that consummate American swindler who time and again put the Brooklyn Bridge up for sale, would surely nod in delighted approval at such a spectacle; and he, for his part, would toss in a bargain for you while he was at it.

那位曾屡次将布鲁克林大桥挂牌出售的旷世美国巨骗乔治·C·帕克,定会对此等景象欣然颔首;而他,还会顺手予你一桩交易。

Jonathan Fay is Reporters' global health and science editor.

乔纳森·法伊Reporters全球健康与科学编辑

Reporters' health and science coverage receives financial support from the Journalists' News Fund and private foundations.

Reporters的健康与科学报道接受记者新闻基金私人基金会财务资助

The Associated Press bears sole responsibility for all content.

美联社对全部内容承担全权责任

For the AP's standards governing collaborations with philanthropic organizations, a list of supporters, and the coverage areas that receive funding, please consult AP.org.

有关美联社与慈善机构合作的标准支持者名录受资助报道领域请查阅AP.org

September 18th, 2026

Trending Articles

The centuries-old Japanese art of flower arranging captivates those in search of inner peace.

The centuries-old Japanese art of flower arranging captivates those in search of inner peace.

数百年日本花道艺术,吸引着寻求内心平静之人

C2Sep 22
Simple Row Covers: The Savior of Late-Summer Vegetables Under Frost Threat

Simple Row Covers: The Savior of Late-Summer Vegetables Under Frost Threat

简易行覆盖物:霜冻威胁下夏末蔬菜的救星

C2Sep 22
Truck driver builds a model of New York City with over 800,000 buildings, now a museum exhibit

Truck driver builds a model of New York City with over 800,000 buildings, now a museum exhibit

卡车司机以80余万座建筑筑就纽约市模型,今成博物馆展品

C2Sep 18
DoorDash and Uber Eats will take over the delivery business for Costco stores in the United States.

DoorDash and Uber Eats will take over the delivery business for Costco stores in the United States.

DoorDash与Uber Eats将承接美国Costco门店配送业务

C2Sep 17
CNN's New Culinary Travel Series: Chef David Chang Across America

CNN's New Culinary Travel Series: Chef David Chang Across America

CNN新美食旅行系列:厨师大卫·张横跨美国

C2Sep 17
The Great American Road Trip: Driven by the Automobile That Created It, and Undermined by It

The Great American Road Trip: Driven by the Automobile That Created It, and Undermined by It

伟大的美国公路旅行:由缔造它的汽车驱动,亦为其所削弱

C2Sep 14
A golf ball in the rubble of the World Trade Center became a symbol of unspeakable loss.

A golf ball in the rubble of the World Trade Center became a symbol of unspeakable loss.

世贸中心废墟中的一枚高尔夫球,化作难以言喻之损失的象征

C2Sep 11
Apple pie—and, of course, mother—has become America's emblematic culinary icon.

Apple pie—and, of course, mother—has become America's emblematic culinary icon.

Apple pie—and, of course, mother—has become America's emblematic culinary icon.

C2Sep 9
The latest Gallup poll reveals that American public satisfaction with schools has plummeted to an all-time low.

The latest Gallup poll reveals that American public satisfaction with schools has plummeted to an all-time low.

盖洛普最新民调揭示:美国公众对学校的满意度已跌至历史低谷

C2Sep 9